图共 3个 表共 5
    • 图  1  两种方法初始化点图

      Figure 1. 

    • 图  2  频率故障率

      Figure 2. 

    • 图  3  收敛曲线图

      Figure 3. 

    • 算法参数设置
      BSA$C = S = 1.5,{a_1} = {a_2} = 1,{\rm FQ} = 5,P \in [0.8,\,1]$ ${\rm FL} \in [0.5,\,0.9]$
      LSABSA${a_1} = {a_2} = 1,{\rm FQ} = 5,P \in [0.8,\,1],{\rm FL} \in [0.5,\,0.9]$ ${C_{\rm{e}}} = {S_{\rm{s}}} = 0,5,{C_{\rm{s}}} = {S_{\rm{e}}} = 2.5$
      本文${a_1} = {a_2} = 1,{\rm FQ} = 5,P \in [0.8,1],{\rm FL} \in [0.5,\,0.9]$
      IoBSA${C_{\rm{e}}} = {S_{\rm{s}}} = 0,5,{C_{\rm{s}}} = {S_{\rm{e}}} = 2$
      CBSA${Q_{\min }} = 0,{Q_{\max }} = 2,A = 0.7,r = 0.4,{P_\alpha } = 0.25$
      CJADE$F = 0.8,{C_r} = 0.5,c = 0.1,p = 0.05$
      文献[10]${\rm{limit}} = 50$

      表 1  部分算法参数列表

    • 参数名参数名
      种群数60任务量10 30 50
      归一化频率0.1~1.0截止时间20~220
      WCET20~50迭代次数1000
      运行次数20惩罚因子5000

      表 2  实验参数列表

    • NPM-ValSt.BSA本文IoBSALSABSACSBAGWOCJADE文献[10]
      375.57Best853.45821.52896.571040.55830.83904.091187.05
      (min)Worst1110.961040.011090.471178.551053.471123.841061.25
      3427.05Mean967.95913.041005.061105.57964.941035.831147.21
      (max)Std.Dev58.1857.6660.3634.8550.4653.9255.25

      表 3  任务量为10的优化结果

    • NPM-ValSt.BSA本文IoBSALSABSACSBAGWOCJADE文献[10]
      1126.70Best4355.133642.204197.414048.744353.494382.294881.90
      (min)Worst5158.384936.645175.335033.735234.8535021.295470.92
      10281.15Mean4771.524368.304739.584519.134681.224677.564928.57
      (max)Std.Dev215.87345.31269.02238.77223.95150.11304.62

      表 4  任务量为30的优化结果

    • NPM-ValSt.BSA本文IoBSALSABSACSBAGWOCJADE文献[10]
      1877.83Best8572.388281.548610.62无效8384.888416.94无效
      (min)Worst10442.7410023.1810149.21无效无效无效无效
      17135.25Mean9557.829319.579513.31无效无效无效无效
      (max)Std.Dev587.00535.50520.50643448.64529852.0175029.971147609.95

      表 5  任务量为50的优化结果